A Tribunal Ruled an Airline’s Chatbot Was the Airline

The Trust Gap

New data paints a sobering picture of where AI-driven customer service actually stands. Forrester found US CX quality fell again to a record low of 68.3 in 2025, while the CFPB reported roughly 6.6 million consumer financial complaints that same year, more than double the prior year. Separately, Salesforce research found that 60% of consumers believe AI makes trust even more critical when dealing with a brand, not less. The pattern across all three is clear: AI is not rescuing broken service; it is exposing it.

Why This Matters for BFSI and Collections

The clearest warning in this data comes from outside financial services but applies directly to it. A tribunal ruled Air Canada was responsible for its chatbot inventing a policy, establishing that a company remains legally accountable for what its AI tells a customer, regardless of whether a human wrote the words. For collections operations, where a voicebot might discuss payment terms, settlement options, or hardship arrangements, that precedent is not abstract. Misinformation from an automated system carries the same liability as misinformation from a human agent. Klarna’s own reversal reinforces the same point from the business side: after positioning its assistant as replacing hundreds of agents, CEO Sebastian Siemiatkowski had to publicly clarify that customers must know there will always be a human available if they want one.

What the Numbers Do Not Say Out Loud

The rising complaint volume is not necessarily evidence that AI performs worse than humans at individual tasks; it is evidence that automation raises the bar for what customers now expect. Gartner’s prediction makes this concrete: by 2027, half of companies that cut customer service staff because of AI will end up rehiring for similar work under different titles. That is an admission that many organizations automated the visible front end without addressing what actually makes AI trustworthy: whether identity, context, and case history survive the handoff between systems and people. Bank of America’s Erica is held up as a model specifically because it stays narrowly scoped and backed by human support.

The Practical Read

For collections and BFSI operations, the operative distinction is not automation versus human service; it is whether escalation is designed in from the start or bolted on as damage control. That means a voicebot handling a payment conversation needs a clear, honest path to a human the moment a conversation moves into complaint territory, emotional distress, or a request the system is not authorized to resolve. As Zendesk CEO Tom Eggemeier put it, AI should be in service to humans. Given the CFPB’s complaint volume and the Air Canada precedent, that is the difference between a deployment that reduces regulatory exposure and one that quietly manufactures it.

[Read the full report]

Related Post

A Bank Just Drew a Hard Line Between What Its AI Can Say & Decide To Do

The Rollout Commonwealth Bank of Australia has begun testing CommBank Companion, an AI-powered conversational assistant built directly into its mobile app, backed by roughly $1 billion in security investment. Unlike most vendor-led AI launches, this one was designed and built entirely in-house by CommBank’s own engineering and data science teams, and it is being tested […]

Most Bank AI Investments Are Stalling

Banking leaders often prioritize the contact center for AI investment because of high-density data environments, such as recorded transcripts and structured contact logs. Banks are pouring millions into voice bots and agent copilots, promising 30 to 45 percent cost reductions and better customer experience. Yet, many institutions are hitting a wall where those gains do […]

When AI Agents Take Action, Mistakes Stop Being Content Errors and Start Being Consequences

The Announcements Google Cloud Summit London 2026 brought a wave of partnership news signaling a shift from AI experimentation to production deployment. HSBC and Google Cloud announced a partnership to deploy more than 200 new AI use cases over the next two years, focused on hyper-personalized wealth management and financial crime detection. Deloitte and Google […]